Can You Appeal a Denial of Social Security Benefits?

If you’ve been denied for an initial claim of social security benefits owed due to an injury or impairment, you shouldn’t feel alone. According to polls conducted both privately and by the Social Security Administration itself nearly 65% of initial claims are denied. That’s a staggering number and can be a disheartening statistic to those unable to provide for themselves or their family.

While many applicants may give up at this point, it’s important to understand that an initial denial is not the end of the road for your SSDI benefits claim. In Florida there is a well-developed system for appealing a denial of disability benefits. While the appeals process has many technical requirements and can be difficult to navigate, applicants are entitled to retain legal counsel to help guide them through the various forms and hearings that may be required in order to obtain their temporary or permanent Social Security benefits. Whether represented by an attorney or going at it on your own, here is an overview of the various stages of the SSDI appeals process.

Denial of Initial Claim for Benefits

Reconsideration of Your Initial Claim

Request an ALJ Hearing

Applicants who are denied with both their initial applications and their reconsideration efforts shouldn’t lose hope. The next stage in the social security benefits appeal process is requesting a hearing from an Administrative Law Judge, or ALJ. The term “judge” is a bit deceiving in this instance. ALJ’s are attorneys who work for the Social Security Administration’s office of Hearings Operations. The ALJ’s are tasked with holding hearings on denials of benefit claims, either at the application stage or denial of ongoing benefits, and upholding or overturning the initial decision.

After a denial of benefits, applicants have 60 days to formally request a hearing by an ALJ. During the hearing claimants for benefits can call witnesses, submit new supporting evidence and affidavits and can testify on their own behalf. Applicants may have an attorney represent them at the hearing who may help with properly phrasing answers to questions, questioning witnesses and making the case for approval to the ALJ. While hearings can take place at the SSA physical office space, they are often performed via video conference to accommodate travel limitations.

Nearly 50% of appeals that come before an ALJ are granted benefits. This makes the ALJ hearing many applicants’ best chance of overcoming any initial deficiencies in their application and receiving a positive outcome to their benefits claim.

Further Appeals

If your claim is denied after reaching the ALJ hearing, all hope is not lost. Claimants still can file an appeal with the Appeals Council. The Appeals Council selection process for cases to review is random. New evidence is generally not allowed to be presented to the council, instead they review for any flaws in the ALJ’s opinion. At this stage only 2-3% of appeals are granted.

Finally, applicants that have been denied at all previous levels can appeal for a Federal Court Review. This involves filing a lawsuit, essentially suing the Social Security Administration. This process can be costly to applicants and has a low chance of success with under 1% of applicants winning their benefits claim at this stage.

The Bottom Line on Appeals

While applicants who have been denied their initial claim shouldn’t lose hope, filing a thorough, well-documented and complete application from the outset gives claimants the best chance at having their disability benefits approved. An experienced Social Security Benefits attorney, such as those with the Law Offices of Justin McMurray, P.A., can help ensure your benefits application is complete and thoroughly documents your injury or disability. If you’re in need of legal representation for an appeal of a denial of benefits, call today for a free consultation of your claim and find out the difference legal representation can make towards getting you and your family the benefits you deserve.


Dedicated lawyers working for clients throughout Florida. Our Jacksonville law firm has been assisting clients for over 10 years. We work hard for you so that you can focus on other matters that are important to you and your family. The future belongs to you! We help you move past the legal matter that may be dominating your daily life right now so that you can focus your attention on your future goals and endeavors.

Regardless of the type of legal matter you may be facing right now, we strive to provide the personal attention you would expect if your case was the only case our attorneys were handling. We have helped thousands of clients throughout Florida. Let us help you with your legal matter.

Fast and easy solutions to the legal matter you are facing. Our goal is to help you find an affordable solution to your legal matter without causing additional stress or work for you. When you retain our law firm, you receive the guidance, support, and legal counsel of a Jacksonville attorney who is knowledgeable, passionate, and dedicated to serving his clients. You also receive the full support of a team of legal professionals who are dedicated to obtaining the best possible outcome in your case.

Contact our office to discover the difference it can make to have a team on your side that puts your best interests above all other concerns. Our Jacksonville lawyers believe everyone deserves to have the benefit of experienced legal counsel. Therefore, our law firm offers free consultations. We do not want the concern about paying for a legal consultation to prevent you from getting help with a legal matter. We want you to have the legal counsel and guidance you need as you choose the best option for you to resolve your legal matter.

Call our Jacksonville law firm at (904) 248-4482 to speak with an attorney now. Do not wait any longer to learn about your legal rights and options regarding your situation.